Warning on SMSF asset valuations

Clarke McEwan Accountants

Warning on SMSF asset valuations

The ATO has issued a warning to trustees of SMSFs about sloppy valuation practices.


ATO data analysis has revealed that over 16,500 self managed superannuation funds (SMSFs) have reported assets as having the same value for three consecutive years. With many of these assets residential or commercial Australian property, you can forgive the ATO for being incredulous.


For trustees of SMSFs, where asset values are consistently reported at the same value, it’s likely your SMSF will be flagged for closer scrutiny by the ATO.


The value of assets in your SMSF impacts on member balances and by default, can impact the amount you can contribute, ability to segregate assets for exempt current pension income, the work test exemption and access to catch-up concessional contributions. And, as we move closer to the implementation of the Division 296 $3m superannuation tax, valuations will be very important for anyone with a member balance close to or in excess of $3m.


If the asset is an in-house asset, for example a related unit trust, then an accurate valuation is essential to ensure the fund remains within the 5% in-house asset limit. If the value of in-house assets rises above 5% of total assets, the asset/s need to be sold to bring the limit back below 5%.


Valuing at market value

Each year, the assets of your SMSF must be valued at ‘market value’ and evidence provided to your auditor. Broadly, market value is the amount that a willing buyer of the asset could reasonably be expected pay to acquire the asset from a willing seller assuming that the buyer and seller are dealing at arm’s length, and everyone acts knowledgeably and prudentially. It’s a common sense test that looks at the value you could reasonably expect to achieve for an asset.


If your SMSF holds collectible and personal use assets like artwork, jewellery, motor vehicles etc., a valuation must be performed by a qualified independent valuer on disposal. This does not necessarily mean that an independent valuation needs to be completed every year but at least every three years would be prudent. If you are not utilising an independent valuer, you will still need to make an active assessment based on market conditions. For example, if you hold artwork and the artist who created your investment artwork died, has this changed the value? Are the primary and secondary markets for the artwork transacting at a higher value? Leaving the value of the asset at its acquisition price calls into question the rationale for acquiring the asset within the fund in the first place. If the asset is unlikely to add any value to your retirement savings, then should it be held in your SMSF when you could achieve a higher rate of return elsewhere?


In most cases, the ATO require trustees to value an asset based on “objective and supportable data”. This means that you should document the asset being valued, a rational explanation for the valuation, and the method in which you arrived at it.


Valuing real property

Commercial and residential real estate does not need to be valued by an independent valuer. But, if there have been significant changes to the property, the market, or the property is unique or difficult to value, it is a good idea to have a written independent valuation from a valuer or estate agent undertaken (their report should also document the valuation method and list comparable properties).


If you are completing the valuation yourself, ensure that you document the time period the valuation applies to and the characteristics that contribute to the valuation. For example, a 10 year old brick four bedroom property on 640m2 of land in what suburb and any features that make it more or less attractive to a buyer, for example proximity to transport. And, you should access credible sales data either on similar properties in the same suburb that have sold recently or from a property data service. More than one source of data is recommended.


The estimates on a lot of online property sales sites are general in nature and not reliable for a valuation of a specific property. The average price change for the suburb however could be used as supporting evidence of your valuation.


For commercial property, net income yields are required to support the valuation. Where the tenants are related parties, for example your business leases a commercial property owned by your SMSF, you will need evidence that a comparative commercial rent is being paid and the rent is keeping pace with the market.


Valuing unlisted companies and unlisted trust investments

Valuing unlisted companies and unlisted investments can be difficult. The financials alone are not enough. But, if your SMSF invested in an unlisted company or shares in a unit trust, then there is an expectation that the trustees made the decision to make the initial acquisition based on the value of the asset, its potential for capital growth and income generation. That is, if you assessed the market value going into the investment, then it should not be a stretch to value the asset each year.


The difficulty for many investors is that in unlisted companies or trusts, the initial investment was broadly equivalent to the cash requirements of the activity being undertaken.


Generally, the starting point is the value of the assets in the entity and/or the consideration paid for the shares/units. For widely held shares or units, this is the entry and exit price.


Where property is the only asset, then the valuation principles for valuing real property are likely to apply.


Where there is no reliable data or market

We’ve seen a few scenarios where the assets purchased or created by the SMSF have no equal or there is no market – the true extent of the value will only really be known when the asset is realised. These unusual items default to either a professional valuation or a viable market assessment. This might be a derivative of the purchase price or data from a related market.


Valuations and the impending Division 296 tax on super earnings

The value of assets will be particularly important for those with super balances close to or above the $3m threshold for the impending Division 296 tax on fund earnings. Because the tax will measure asset values and tax the growth in earnings above the $3m threshold, accurate valuations will be important to ensure that the fund does not pay tax when it does not need to, and to reduce the likelihood of anomalies artificially inflating tax payable.

By Clarke McEwan July 23, 2026
Discover practical tax planning strategies for medical specialists in Australia. Learn how proactive structuring, superannuation, practice planning and wealth strategies can help you build long-term financial success.
By Clarke McEwan July 19, 2026
From 1 July 2026, thousands more businesses—including accounting and professional services firms—are now regulated under Australia’s anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing (AML/CTF) laws.
By Clarke McEwan July 3, 2026
With the start of the 2026–27 financial year, SMSF trustees should take a proactive approach to ensure funds remain compliant and well positioned. Below is a concise checklist of the key legislative changes, compliance deadlines and practical steps trustees should prioritise. 1. Review Transfer Balance Cap and Pension Planning Indexation of the general TBC: From 1 July 2026 the general transfer balance cap (TBC) increases from $2.0 million to $2.1 million. Members should check whether their personal transfer balance cap is eligible for indexation, particularly if they started a pension before the latest indexation dates. The ATO will calculate a member’s entitlement to indexation of their personal TBC, however, this will be based on reported transfer balance account (TBA) events (eg, commencement or commutation of a pension). It’s important that all TBA events up to 30 June 2026 have been reported to the ATO to ensure an accurate calculation of TBC indexation entitlement. Legacy pensions: The five-year legacy pension exit measure (7 Dec 2024 – 6 Dec 2029) remains available. Where clients hold legacy lifetime, life expectancy or market-linked pensions, confirm deed powers and consider the interaction with Division 296 and commutation rules before acting. 2. Update Contribution Strategies and Caps Higher caps for 2026–27: The concessional contributions cap rises to $32,500 and the standard non-concessional cap becomes $130,000. However, the non-concessional cap is subject the member’s 30 June 2026 total superannuation balance (TSB) being less than $2.1 million. Review your planned contributions to avoid cap breaches. Bring-forward and TSB thresholds: Check each member’s TSB at 30 June 2026 prior to applying bring-forward rules in 2026-27. Thresholds and allowable bring-forward periods changed for 2026–27. The increase to the standard non-concessional cap means the maximum bring forward cap has increased from $360,000 to $390,000. However, if the bring-forward rule was triggered in 2024-25 or 2025-26, the member does not get the benefit of the increase. 3. Pension Minimums, TRIS and ECPI Risks Minimum pension percentages: Check minimum pension percentages for age groups and ensure pensions meet the standards to avoid breaches and potential loss of fund tax exempt income. For a transition to retirement (TTR) pension, in addition to making at least the minimum pension payment, make sure you don’t exceed the 10% maximum. Also, if turning 65 in 2026-27, a TTR pension automatically moves into retirement phase and has TBC consequences. Speak to your adviser about implications and options well before your 65th birthday. Commutations and starting pensions: Follow correct commencement and commutation procedures; incorrect handling can trigger multiple events and adverse tax outcomes. Report all TBA events to the ATO by the due date. 4. Review Related Party Loans and Update Interest Rate The ATO document PCG 2016/5 sets out many of the terms and conditions a related party loan should have, including the interest rate. These are commonly referred to as the ‘safe harbour provisions’. Each year, the interest rate of the loan should be reviewed and updated in line with the relevant rate determined in May immediately before the commence of the financial year. The rate for the 2025-26 year was 8.95% for property and 10.95% for listed securities. As a result of increases in the RBA's cash rate over the last 12 months there has been an increase to the safe harbour interest rates to 9.35% and 11.35% for property and listed securities respectively. The repayments of any related party loans that are complying with the safe harbour provisions will need to be adjusted to reflect these new rates. 5. Check Compliance for Payroll and Contributions (SuperStream 3.0 / Payday Super) NPP readiness: From 1 July 2026 funds and employers must be capable of receiving contributions via the New Payments Platform (NPP). Ensure the SMSF bank account can accept Osko/PayID and other NPP payments. Member Verification Requests (MVRs): Employers will use MVRs to confirm whether a fund can accept a contribution. SMSFs receiving employer contributions should be prepared to respond to MVRs promptly (within required timeframes). Generally, SuperStream messages will be received in the SMSF administration platform that is used by the SMSF’s accountant or administrator. Members should inform their SMSF accountant or administrator if their employer will be sending a message via the MVR to confirm whether their SMSF can accept the contribution. Closely held employees: If your SMSF has related employees, confirm whether SuperStream exemptions apply and ensure payroll systems are updated as late lodgements may result in penalties. Remember the ATO can remove fund details from the SMSF lookup database if tax returns are overdue. This could impact on a fund’s ability to receive employer contributions. 6. Consider the Division 296 Transitional Rules and Tax Traps 2026–27 transitional year treatment: The 2026–27 year has specific transitional rules for Division 296 where the relevant TSB is measured at 30 June 2027. Trustees should assess whether electing to set a Div 296 cost base to 30 June 2026 market values is appropriate. This election does not need to be made until the lodgement of the 2027 SMSF Annual Return (tax return), and if made, applies to all assets and has consequences for capital losses and later adjustments. Seek tailored advice before electing. 7. Practical Housekeeping Deed powers and trustee structure: For SMSFs with individual trustees, consider whether a corporate trustee is a potentially better option. Talk to you adviser about these potential benefits and the process to change. Ensure that any changes to the trustee structure is reported to the relevant authority within the required timeframe (eg, the ATO, ASIC). Document everything: Keep clear records of trustee decisions, valuations used for elections, contribution timing evidence and communications with employers — documentation is key for the annual audit and if the ATO queries an event. Preparing now will reduce 2026-27 year-end stress and help avoid costly compliance issues. Speak to us if you have any questions or wish to discuss any of the issues raised above.
By Clarke McEwan July 3, 2026
The Tax Ombudsman has reported a dramatic 127% increase in complaints about the ATO this financial year (to 30 April 2026), with nearly 3,000 complaints received in the first ten months. Debt collection, penalties, and tax debt interest charges have dominated the issues raised. Tax Ombudsman Ruth Owen has linked the sharp rise directly to the ATO’s intensified focus on recovering outstanding debts amid tighter economic conditions. Many SME owners and individuals are feeling the pressure from cash flow challenges, rising costs, and stricter ATO enforcement. Why Complaints are Rising Debt collection accounted for around 23% of complaints, followed by payment-related issues (16%) and penalties plus interest (15%). Common concerns include: Refund offsets against debts Director Penalty Notices Challenges in setting up or maintaining payment plans The rapid accumulation of General Interest Charge (GIC) on overdue amounts This surge reflects real-world pressures: businesses navigating post-pandemic recovery, higher interest rates, and increased ATO activity to close the tax gap. For many clients, these issues create significant stress and can distract from core operations. Practical wins: Relief is Possible The good news? The Ombudsman’s office is proving effective as an independent escalation point. Around 31% of complaints relating to penalties and interest resulted in some form of debt reduction or remission. This highlights that persistence and proper representation can sometimes deliver favourable outcomes when initial ATO decisions feel overly harsh or inconsistent. Important Developments on GIC Remission A key theme in the complaints data is the GIC – the daily interest applied to unpaid tax debts. In March 2026, the Tax Ombudsman released a major review titled In the Interest of Fairness, which examined the ATO’s handling of GIC remission requests. The review identified inconsistent decision-making, unclear guidance, and communication gaps that left many taxpayers confused about their options. It made several recommendations, including clearer upfront interest-free payment plans for compliant taxpayers. The ATO’s response has been positive. It accepted all recommendations and has already begun implementing improvements, such as: Enhanced website guidance with practical examples New, more user-friendly remission application forms A $2,500 cap on phone approvals with a dedicated review team for larger requests to improve consistency Better support frameworks for vulnerable taxpayers These changes should hopefully make the process fairer and more predictable going forward, but sometimes best intentions don’t translate into practical reality so we will have to wait and see how this plays out. What this Means for You 1. Act early on tax debts: Don’t wait for the ATO to contact you. If you’re facing cash flow pressure, engage proactively before penalties and GIC escalate. Early action often leads to better terms. 2. Keep detailed records: Strong supporting documentation is crucial when seeking remission of penalties or interest. Demonstrate why the delay occurred (eg, unexpected revenue drop, illness, or system issues) and what steps you’ve taken to rectify it. 3. Use professional representation: Tax agents can liaise directly with the ATO on your behalf, prepare strong submissions, and escalate to the Tax Ombudsman where appropriate. This often leads to faster and more commercially practical outcomes than dealing with the matter alone. While the ATO must collect revenue fairly, the Ombudsman plays a vital role in ensuring processes remain reasonable and transparent. With economic headwinds continuing, understanding your rights and options has never been more important.  If you’re concerned about a tax debt, penalty notice, or GIC charge, contact our team promptly. Early intervention can significantly reduce costs and protect your business or personal finances. For more information, visit the Tax Ombudsman’s complaints snapshots and reports: Complaints snapshots - Tax Ombudsman
By Clarke McEwan July 3, 2026
The ATO is sharpening its focus on how taxpayers generating income from personal services deal with that income for tax purposes. In a recent Spotlight bulletin, Small Business Assistant Commissioner Tony Poulakis highlighted the release of Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2025/5. This guideline clarifies the ATO’s compliance approach to the “alienation” of personal services income (PSI) — essentially, arrangements which involve routing income earned through your personal skills and efforts via a company or trust, rather than receiving it directly. Why the ATO Is Interested Many business owners operate through a company or trust rather than earning income personally. In many cases this is entirely legitimate and provides commercial benefits such as asset protection, flexibility and succession planning. However, where income is generated primarily from the efforts, skills or reputation of one individual, the ATO is concerned about arrangements that divert income away from that individual in order to reduce tax. Even where a business is able to pass certain tests to be classified as a Personal Services Business (PSB) under the tax rules and falls outside the strict PSI attribution rules, the ATO has made it clear that general anti-avoidance provisions in Part IVA can apply if the arrangement is primarily tax-driven. If Part IVA applies then this can lead to higher tax liabilities as well as significant penalties and interest charges. What Does the ATO Consider Low Risk? The ATO's guidance focuses heavily on whether the individual generating the income receives an appropriate share of the profits. Generally, an arrangement is more likely to be considered low risk where: The individual who performs the work receives most of the economic benefit through salary, wages, bonuses, director fees or trust distributions. Profits retained in a company are kept for genuine and short-term business reasons. Family members or associates are only paid reasonable amounts for genuine work performed. For example, retaining profits in a company to fund the purchase of new equipment in the short-term could be viewed favourably if there is evidence supporting those plans and the company actually follows through with these plans. What Will Attract ATO Attention? The ATO has specifically identified a number of higher-risk behaviours, including: Splitting income with family members who have made little or no contribution to earning that income. Retaining substantial profits in a company without a genuine short-term commercial purpose. Directing profits generating from someone’s personal services to entities or beneficiaries primarily because they are taxed at lower rates or because they have tax losses. The ATO’s expectations in this area are very strict. The greater the mismatch between who performed the work and who is ultimately taxed on the profits from that work, the greater the likelihood of ATO scrutiny. A Limited Opportunity to Review Existing Arrangements The ATO has provided a transition period for taxpayers who genuinely review and adjust their arrangements. Businesses that take genuine steps to move from higher-risk arrangements to lower-risk arrangements by 30 June 2027 are unlikely to face Part IVA action in relation to those arrangements if reviewed by the ATO. This is not an amnesty, but it is an opportunity for business owners to proactively assess their position and make changes where necessary. What Should Business Owners Do? Now is an ideal time to review how profits are being distributed within your structure. Questions worth considering include: Are retained profits supported by documented short-term commercial reasons? Are payments to family members commercially justifiable? Would your arrangements withstand ATO scrutiny if reviewed? If you operate through a company or trust and derive income largely from your personal skills or efforts, it is important to review existing arrangements in light of the ATO’s updated guidance. A proactive review today may prevent costly issues tomorrow.
By Clarke McEwan July 3, 2026
One of the most significant changes to the Australian superannuation system in decades has now commenced. From 1 July 2026, Payday Super requires employers to ensure super contributions reach employee super funds within seven business days of each payday. For many businesses, this represents a major shift from a quarterly payment cycle to a more frequent, real-time obligation. While the Government is aiming to get super into employee accounts faster and help close the national super gap, the new system introduces new compliance, cash flow and administrative considerations for employers. Businesses that have prepared well should find the transition manageable, but those still relying on quarterly processes need to act quickly to avoid significant problems. What Exactly Has Changed? Under the previous rules, employers generally had until 28 days after the end of each quarter to make super contributions. Under Payday Super, the clock now starts on each “Qualifying Earnings” (QE) day — essentially your payday for salary, wages, commissions, bonuses and certain contractor payments. Key Requirements Contributions must be received and allocated to the employee’s fund within 7 business days of payday (there are limited exceptions to this).Shortfalls are now calculated per QE day rather than quarterly. The ATO’s Small Business Superannuation Clearing House has closed, meaning businesses previously using the service must now use a SuperStream-compliant alternative. The ATO’s Small Business Superannuation Clearing House has closed, meaning businesses previously using the service must now use a SuperStream-compliant alternative. Penalties are also tougher. The administrative uplift can reach 60% of the shortfall (with reductions available for early voluntary disclosure), although the Superannuation Guarantee Charge itself is deductible in more circumstances. The ATO’s first-year compliance approach (PCG 2026/1) adopts a risk-based view, with businesses that make genuine efforts to comply and promptly rectify mistakes generally treated as lower risk. However, if an employee reports a problem to the ATO then don’t expect the ATO to ignore this. Managing the June – July Changeover There is a technical quirk in the rules which could catch out unsuspecting employers, especially when it comes to SG contributions made across the month of July 2026. If a business has paid employees during the June 2026 quarter then the SG deadline for this quarter would normally be 28 July 2026. However, many employers have decided to pay the SG amount for the June quarter before this deadline to reduce the risk of accidentally triggering a SGC problem. This is because any SG contributions made from 1 July 2026 will reduce the super owing for the June quarter first, before any remaining amount is used to meet Payday Super obligations relating to pay runs that occur in July. The best way to manage this situation to avoid SGC liabilities really depends on the dates of any July pay runs. Please contact us if you need help identifying any potential problems or to help come up with a practical solution. Three Practical Steps to Take Now 1. Review Your Systems: Confirm that your payroll software, clearing house and internal processes are operating correctly under the new rules. If you have not already done so, review pay codes and contribution workflows to ensure QEs are correctly identified. 2. Monitor Cash Flow and Processes: Assess the impact of more frequent super payments on cash flow. Review approval processes, onboarding procedures and the handling of bonuses or out-of-cycle payments. 3. Strengthen Controls and Communication: Ensure payroll and finance teams understand the new requirements and have appropriate controls in place. Ongoing monitoring and periodic reviews will help identify issues before they become compliance problems. The interdependencies between payroll systems, clearing houses and super funds mean small oversights can quickly create larger compliance issues. Businesses that continue to monitor and refine their processes will be best placed to meet their obligations. At Clarke McEwan, we are helping clients navigate the practical implications of Payday Super through readiness reviews, payroll process assessments and cash flow planning. Our goal is to help businesses remain compliant while building stronger and more efficient systems. If you would like to discuss how Payday Super affects your business, contact your Clarke McEwan adviser. We can help identify any remaining gaps and ensure your systems and processes continue to operate effectively under the new system.
More Posts